Our Reviews

1115 5th Avenue
New York, NY 10128

+1(212) 517-4500

5 stars 5
Although I was expecting a long wait, I was seen after only a couple of minutes of my appointment. Dr. Rosenthal was friendly efficient and easily explained my options. His staff was equally friendly and helpful. As an initial visit I'd highly recommend visiting Dr. Rosenthal.Update: I had surgery on my my left eye on Nov. 14th. A week later at my post-op appointment my eyesight was 20/20 in that eye. This was an unexpected surprise as we went not sure this was achievable with my astigmatisms and other abnormalities. I've been wearing glasses since I was 10 years old and to be able to sue my computer, see TV and have clear vision in the distance is truly remarkable.I can't say enough how please I am so far with my results.Update: Jan 11, 2023. It's now a bout 45 days after my second surgery. The results are way above my expectations. I basically have 20/20 vision for mid and long distance. I need 2.50 power for reading glasses, but can read my phone and computer without reading glasses but it is more comfortable with reading glasses.Dr. Rosenthal is doing cutting edge cataract surgery. If you have astigmatisms and need cataract surgery I can't recommend him enough. The result has even surprised Dr. Rosenthal on how excellent my results have been.His team is also excellent and answered every question in a timely and professional manner.I give Dr. Rosenthal my highest praise for his amazing work.

5 stars 5
Dr. Alexandra Scherk is thorough, patient and has a great bed-side manner.

5 stars 5
Everybody was friendly, efficace, very professional and a rarity in the medical field, right on time!

5 stars 5
Caring and considerate from Bibie at the reception desk to Dr. Alexandra Scherk who is thorough, professional and kind. She gives you all the time you need. My husband and I were originally patients for over 20 years of Dr. Gorman who has retired. I feel so fortunate that his practice now has Dr. Scherk.

5 stars 5
Very Pleasant Experience with his Staff, Very Professional, Very Well Organized.Dr. Rosenthal was Great! Not to mention He's been awarded one of the Top 2022 Cataract Surgeon in America.

Calendar Icon
Request Appointment
Eye Icon
Cataract Self-Test
Money Icon
Make a Payment
Telehealth Appointments
Review Us

Book your consultation today and take advantage of our end-of-year special pricing!